Introducing Illini bucks to campus would certainly create an
interesting array of opportunities for students to illustrate which services,
activities, events or goods they preference. If I understand correctly, the
hypothetical situation introduced in the prompt gives each student an equal
number of “Illini bucks” at the bringing of the semester. Before spending this
campus currency, students would already have an understanding of how much each
illini buck can purchase on campus. For example, maybe students can use these
bucks to get in the front of the line for access to sporting events, concerts,
registering for classes, interviews, library tables, gym lockers etc. It seems
as though the potential uses are endless.
There are many aspects of everyday campus life that I wish I
could simply, “cut in line”, some of which I mentioned above. We learn in
economics that each person has his or her own set of preferences, which makes
up an indifference curve and influences their spending habits. All things being
equal, and there being no seniority for picking classes based on credit hours,
I would choose to spend my illini bucks on picking classes before others. I
personally think tuition is meant to purchase education and using this
imaginary currency, paid for by my tuition, to increase my learning experience
would provide me with the most utility. It is known, that many of the best,
interesting, even “easiest” classes fill up first during registration. Those
who have the most credit hours in their respective class have the opportunity
to pick courses that will, in theory, give them the best educational advantage.
There has been many instances where I would (not literally) wish to pay someone
just to save me a spot in a highly regarded course. We mentioned in class that there are many
ways other schools across the nation allow students to choose courses; I think
introducing illini bucks would greatly change that process here on campus.
However, not everyone shares the same preferences. I know
many friends who would rather choose to spend their Illini bucks on getting
first picks for basketball season tickets, or the best parking spots on
campus. I cannot say what percentage of
students would apply their currency to educational vs recreational benefits,
though it would be an interesting study. I have to imagine that the majority of
students would choose to use the currency on registration, tutoring session,
job fairs, etc. After all, this is the reason why we go to school. Pricing all these options out would be an interesting
process.
Quite frankly, I think it would be impossible to set an
effective fixed pricing scheme for illini buck purchases. I don’t see an
efficient situation where the campus government could accurately determine the
preferences of the entire campus and as a result set prices on a supply/demand
basis. If prices are set too low, disproportionate to demand, students will end
up still entering a first come first serve basis system as the services in high
demand will have long lines with people wanting to spend their bucks first. If
prices are too high, then students, I assume, will end up spending the majority
of their bucks on educational related services, while all other services
continue to operate on a first come first service basis as people deplete their
funds.
I think this fixed price system would result in a secondary
market for educational and recreational related services. As people change
preferences throughout the semester I would expect prices to fluctuate and
people willing to either exchange real money, or illini bucks for services in
demand.
I agree with you about a fixed priced scheme. But what about a floating pricing scheme? Might that work? Also, you haven't considered that somebody who is already in an oversubscribed class, somebody you didn't hire in advance, might be willing to sell their seat for Illinibucks that they could use elsewhere. Do you think that might work?
ReplyDeleteI believe a floating price scheme would work, however, I think since there is a finite amount of illini bucks a secondary mark would still emerge. I imagine this floating price scheme would work similar to an auction, with most purchases taking place at the beginning of the semester.
ReplyDeleteTo your second point, I think I touched upon that briefly by mentioned changing preference as the semester goes on. In a secondary market, a student could sell their highly coveted class position or other seat and possibly make a return on their initial purchase. I have a feeling that if this system were introduced students would find many ways to take advantage of this process, maybe even colluding with other students to create deals that may not be fair to others.